Following years of litigation and a trial, the Borough of Englewood Cliffs (the Borough) was found to have failed for decades to comply with its constitutional obligations to provide its fair share of affordable housing. Thereafter, the Borough entered into settlement agreements to allow affordable housing to be built. Following a change in the membership of the Borough's council, however, the Borough moved to vacate the settlement agreements, contending that two council members who had voted for the agreements had conflicts of interest. That argument was in direct contradiction to the position the Borough had taken before the trial court and in a related litigation where the Borough had argued that there were no conflicts of interest.
The court affirms the trial court's rejection of the Borough's arguments for several reasons, including that the Borough was judicially estopped from claiming any conflict. The record establishes that for years the Borough has stalled various efforts to allow affordable housing to be built. The court emphasizes that the time for delaying constitutional compliance is over.
